View From The Booth: Could LA and New York end up playing in Toronto?

With both clubs playing well, Rogondino asks the question: Is Friday’s game a preview of MLS Cu

buddle vs NY

Photo Credit: 
Getty Images

this a possible MLS Cup preview? 
Certainly there are a number of MLS executives that would like to think
so. Even without Thierry Henry in the lineup for New
York Friday night, there will still be some of the best talent
MLS has to offer on display.  What treat
for you fans here in Southern California.

Galaxy come in unbeaten in their last three games for the first time since
early June, and maybe this is an indication that LA is getting back into
form.  Although the team did not play
well in the win against D.C. United on Saturday, I have said all along that the
sign of a championship caliber team is one that can grind out a result even
when not performing to the best of its abilities.  It worked against D.C., but trying to do the
same against the Red Bulls this week could lead to a far different result. 

biggest concern for me is LA’s central defense. 
For much of this season there have been three players that have occupied
the two central defender spot: Gregg Berhalter, Omar
Gonzalez and Leonardo. Two of the three, the two that did such
a good job against New York at Red
Bull Arena last month, Berhalter and Gonzalez, will not be available for Bruce
Arena this time around.  Berhalter is
still recovering from an injury and Gonzalez will miss the match due to yellow
card accumulation. 

Galaxy will most likely look to Leonardo and Yohance Marshall at the center
back position.  Leonardo has been
effective at times this year, but keep in mind that when the young Brazilian
has played, it has been next to Berhalter or Gonzalez.  Marshall
made his MLS debut on Saturday against D.C., and played very well.  He spent the past five months on loan to
Austin Aztex, playing in 24 games for the club, so the good news is that he is
not just coming in this cold. However, even with those games under his belt, it
will be vital for Sean Franklin and
Todd Dunivant to continue their stellar play at the outside back positions and
organize the LA defense more than they would with either Gregg or Omar in
there.  It is also worth mentioning that
last year Bruce Arena told me he had “a lot of confidence” in Yohance, and that
he expects Marshall to be in the
Galaxy plans for years to come.  Seems
like a pretty good endorsement if you ask me.

imagine the rest of LA’s lineup will look the same.  The Buddle-Kirovski connection up front seems
to have given Edson some renewed energy. 
Having a veteran like Jovan next to the MLS leading scorer takes a lot
of the physical challenges from opposing defenders away.  Edson no longer has to be the sole target to
win all of the long balls in the air. 
Plus, although Kirovski is not as quick as he used to be, he is still as
intelligent on the field as ever.  Jovan
combines very well with other players, and more often than not makes the right
pass at the right time during the run of play. 
I get the sense that this is the connection Bruce Arena has been looking
for throughout the season, and the one that we will see for the remainder of
the year.

question that the Galaxy (and specifically Bruce Arena) will have to answer is
just how much time he will be able to get out of David Beckham on Friday
night.  His minutes have increased in
each of his two appearances this season, playing the final 37 minutes of the
win over United.  Bruce has been very cautious
with Beckham to this point, but you have to wonder if this is the week where
Arena loosens the reins on his Designated Player.  We all know that Beckham likes to be on the
field for the big games, and this without question qualifies as that.

Beckham and Arena were coy about their plans when speaking to reporters on
Wednesday, so your guess is as good as mine at this point. But whatever the
Galaxy coach ends up going with, I think that this game will see some offensive

was very surprised to see just one goal scored the first time these teams met
last month at Red Bull Arena.  When Edson
Buddle struck just 10 minutes into the game at Red Bull Arena back in early
August, my mind told me “here we go with another New
York shootout”.  Fast
forward 80 minutes to the final whistle, and Buddle’s strike ended up as the
game-winner.  Some will disagree with me,
but I felt LA was under a ton of pressure in the second half and really were
fortunate to get out of there with three points, let alone one.  The Red Bulls had several chances to score in
the last 20 minutes of the game, but for one reason or another could not put
the ball in the back of the net.

with out Henry in the fold, the Red Bulls are a very dangerous team and they
have a long list of weapons with which to attack the Galaxy defense.

Marquez has solidified the central midfield, and taken some of the pressure off
of Juan Pablo Angel to always hold the ball going forward.  The recent addition of Mehdi Ballouchy, a
player that is still trying to live up to the potential from when he arrived in
the league, gives New York another
great linking option in the center of the field.  The one area that Hans Backe’s team might be
vulnerable is on the back line and in goal. 
Rookie Tim Ream has shown confidence in the back playing along side
Carlos Mendes, but what those two, and the rest of the New
York defense lacks in speed. 
Bouna Coundol is one of the best when it comes to shot-stopping, but he
can be rattled early in matches. And for how good he is with his hands, he can
be equally bad with the ball at his feet. If the Galaxy can get at him early
they should be in a good position, but if they let him build with confidence as
the game goes on it could get tricky.

Hits –

New York has three losses since the
World Cup break, and all three have come against teams that are chasing the
Supporters Shield (LA, Columbus, &
Real Salt Lake).
As a result, the Red Bulls need this game to show that they should be in the
discussion when it comes to talking about the elite teams in MLS.  I imagine that has to be one of the talking
points for head coach Hans Backe.

fans have to enjoy the sight of Dema Kovalenko on the field along with
Juninho.  Similar to my comments above
concerning Kirovski and Buddle, it looks like this is the midfield partnership
Bruce Arena has been looking for.  It is
a perfect balance of grit & bite from Kovalenko, with the skill and
precision passing from the young Brazilian.

urged you last week to make this week’s game truly feel like a hostile
environment when the Red Bulls arrive. 
With the announcement of the grass berm being opened up for general
admission, it sounds like the HDC will be rocking!  Leading the way no doubt will be all the
club’s supporters groups from their respective spots.  I love hearing the Angel City Brigade and LA
Riot Squad to doing the call and response chants during the run of play.  Keep it up Galaxy fans; this is going to be a
great evening of soccer.


Bookmark and Share


Henry ruled out of clash away to LA with knee injury
NY's Márquez fit, ready to go against LA
Arena looking forward to battle of midfields
Friday night clash still a must see
Long road leads back to bigs for LA's Marshall
Henry's absence won't distract Galaxy
The Throw-In: Stars behind the stars in LA-NY clash